Skip to main content
Personal Finance Professional – setting standards and guiding the profession - return to the homepage Personal Finance Professional logo
  • Search
  • Visit Personal Finance Professional on Instagram
  • Personal Finance Professional on Twitter
  • Visit @PersonalFinanceSociety on Facebook
Visit the website of the Chartered Insurance Institute Logo of the Chartered Insurance Institute

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • News analysis
  • Features
  • Study room
  • Opinion
  • PFS Radio
  • Digital magazine
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Personal Finance Professional Issues
  • SUMMER 2022
Features

Where are the female financial planners?

Share on
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print
Open-access content Monday 13th June 2022
Authors
Samantha Secomb
f

There is currently a shortage of financial planners in the UK, so why are only 16% of them women? Samantha Secomb investigates

Some 84% of financial advisers in the UK are men. With so many initiatives encouraging more women into the profession, why is there still such a large gender imbalance?

The financial advice sector is made up of many small firms and these small companies struggle to provide expertise and resources to train and develop advisers internally. This lack of new talent leaves retiring advisers struggling to find individuals willing to buy equity stakes and succeed them in their practices. There is no fundamental reason why more women cannot be competent and effective financial advisers. But why are they unable to make the transition into the adviser role, or are they in fact choosing not to advise clients?

Navigating careers

I conducted semi-structured interviews with 15 professionally qualified women based in the UK to better understand how women navigate careers in financial services. Most of these women ended up in financial planning roles by accident. It was their preferred option when seeking paid work, rather than a pre-selected option for which they had studied, prepared and sought out an entry-level role. Those who selected a career path in financial planning associated it with helping others and being a positive influence on people’s financial wellbeing.

Some women transferred away from the sales environment to a paraplanning role. This was to escape some undesirable parts of the role, while capitalising on their skills, knowledge and qualifications. Others reported being able to earn more in part-time or freelance roles. Though this can necessitate moving jobs, changing employers or employment status to accommodate any family obligations. Those who remained in financial services reported their intention to return to a more focused career stage once these demands reduce.

Based on the responses where women thrive on being involved in work they feel good about, their desire to be appreciated, trusted and liked, clients could benefit from a rewarding experience with a female financial planner

Some paraplanning firms have structures that deliberately seem to target female employees. With advisers outsourcing technical work to these firms, this contributes to the ceiling for qualified women. The most common stereotypical judgement in the research was around the idea that women would be less committed to a career because they were likely to prioritise having a family at some stage in their lives. This is perceived as a disadvantage to them because men are assumed to be able to continue working, regardless of whether they have a family or not.

One interviewee described how she felt discriminated against, simply because it was expected for her to have children: “I basically feel that because I was married and I was of childbearing age, I think that held me back quite a bit from promotion and stuff like that. Nobody will say it, but we all think it. We don’t want to take on somebody who’s going to go on maternity. Because what do we do? As I said, I think that’s always in the back of your mind when you hire a woman.”

This stereotyping was identified as having a negative influence on women’s career progression. There was also a sense of acceptance among these candidates that this was normal and they had no expectation that this discrimination would change, as explained by another interviewee: “Every male candidate was told that he could become an adviser. But women were constantly being told that the best they could do is probably be a paraplanner if they tried hard. And that happened all the time. And it was so, so wrong. And I think we probably were all conditioned somewhere there in the background, without even realising that, you know, the furthest we can go is to be a paraplanner. If we’re lucky.”

Historic culture

Women are not perceived as a natural fit for the role of financial planner. It is traditionally seen as a competitive and demanding role, more aligned to the natural characteristics associated with men. The role is about long-term forecasting and planning for clients, with periodic, disciplined reviews to measure and adjust progress against planning.

Unlike a stockbroker, where the timing of decisions and actions is sensitive, a financial planner does not need to respond immediately, but can plan and organise work in advance. The long hours and full-time availability stereotypically associated with the role are a by-product of the historic sales culture. Presenteeism is also an artificial echo of the past but continues to inform the stereotypical benchmark for success.

Changing the culture of traditionally male-dominated workplaces dominating the financial planning sector is a slow process. But, considering the current shortage of financial planners in the UK, it makes sense to attract more female talent. Based on the responses where women thrive on being involved in work they feel good about, their desire to be appreciated, trusted and liked, clients could benefit from a rewarding experience with a female financial planner.

The diversity of mixed gender teams introduces fresh thinking around solution building, better risk management and quality control, as client outcomes are balanced with production targets, with the risk and reward shared by the entire team. This type of team approach serves clients well, helps the business manage risk and creates more inclusive work structures.

To read the full report – Women’s career progression in the UK financial planning sector, visit: www.thepfs.org/103584

Samantha Secomb is a Chartered financial planner at Women’s Wealth

Image credit | Alice Mollon/ IKON

v3 Linked PFP_Summer 2022.jpg
This article appeared in our SUMMER 2022 issue of Personal Finance Professional .
Click here to view this issue

You may also be interested in...

TRJX

President's opinion - driving diversity

Sarah Lord examines the lack of diversity in the profession and what is being done to change it
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
yf

Retirement - best laid plans

"Liz Booth examines whether reduced life expectancy figures post-pandemic are affecting how people plan their finances"
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
ty

Steel focus

Matthew Connell explains the impact of the FCA’s British Steel pension compensation scheme
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
ih

Getting a grip on green

As various bodies seek to establish a common taxonomy for ESG investing, Dewi John examines the tensions between the different approaches
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
uy

Lending landscape

Marc Shoffman explores what the Bank of England’s plan to ditch rules limiting massive mortgages means for brokers
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
web_p38-39_Mark-of-professionals_credit_shutterstock_652722862.png

Mark of professionalism

Rebecca Aston and Hayley Brown reveal why customers are more likely than ever to ‘Choose Chartered’
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content

Latest from Features

n;

Rethinking retirement

The cost-of-living crisis and politics are playing havoc with many people’s retirement plans, as Liz Booth reports
Friday 17th February 2023
Open-access content
sh

Economic outlook - how can advisers help?

As 2023 begins where last year left off, with widespread strikes, high energy costs, bad weather and a cost-of-living crisis, Liz Booth looks for signs of recovery
Friday 17th February 2023
Open-access content
yktc

Rebuilding the mortgage market

Aamina Zafar reports on a market still recovering from the disastrous mini-Budget and rising interest rates
Friday 17th February 2023
Open-access content

Latest from SUMMER 2022

kyc

Q&A - Summer 2022

Q&A - Summer 2022
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
uykc

Technical Q&A Summer 2022

Key answers on pilot trusts and salary sacrifice
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
rtx

Roadshows return

Caroline Stuart is a Chartered financial planner at Sparrow Paraplanning
Monday 13th June 2022
Open-access content
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

BECOME A MEMBER

BECOME A MEMBER

SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT

SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT
PFP
​
FOLLOW US
Twitter
LinkedIn
Youtube
CONTACT US
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7880 6200
Email
Advertise with us
​

About the PFS

About us
Membership
Qualifications
Events

PFP magazine

Digital magazine
Podcasts
Blog
News

General Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Write for PFP Magazine
Want to receive PFP Magazine
Not a member but interested in knowing more? Click here.

© 2023 • PFP Magazine is published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ