Skip to main content
Personal Finance Professional – setting standards and guiding the profession - return to the homepage Personal Finance Professional logo
  • Search
  • Visit Personal Finance Professional on Instagram
  • Personal Finance Professional on Twitter
  • Visit @PersonalFinanceSociety on Facebook
Visit the website of the Chartered Insurance Institute Logo of the Chartered Insurance Institute

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
  • News analysis
  • Features
  • Study room
  • Opinion
  • PFS Radio
  • Digital magazine
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Personal Finance Professional Issues
  • SPRING 2022
Features

Radical Review

Share on
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print
Open-access content Tuesday 15th February 2022
Authors
Matthew Connell
web_p18-19_Radical-review_CREDIT_iStock-1130633985.png

Matthew Connell reveals the regulatory challenge advisers face from the FCA’s retail investment review

It may feel as though the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has been reviewing retail investments forever, but its most recent work on the sector is a radical departure from everything that has gone before.

The retail investment review began with a call for evidence in September 2020. Since then, it hasn't received the kind of attention that FCA initiatives usually get, mainly because it has not been accompanied by a huge raft of new rules that are meat and drink to the compliance project brigade.

However, the scope of the investment review is enormous – it includes cash savings, mainstream investments, high-risk investments and investment scams. It is probably the first review of investments that has looked at every possible destination – legal and illegal – for investors’ wealth.

The review is also groundbreaking because the FCA strategy identifies very clear and measurable outcomes. For example, it targets a 20% reduction in the number of consumers with higher risk tolerance holding £10,000 in cash by 2025 – this is a very ‘SMART’ objective that is designed to prevent consumers having their savings eroded by inflation when they should be investing for the medium to long term.

Many of these problems arise from a lack of financial advice. For example, in 2018 the FCA observed that non-advised investors had “often not thought about the investment choices of drawdown”, adding: “As a result, we have seen some customers remain in low-risk assets after following lifestyling strategies. We have seen others stay in cash funds because they have had to enter into a new contract to access drawdown. Both these options increase the risk of customers running out of money in retirement, or having less money than they were expecting.”

The FCA acknowledges the problems arising from a lack of advice, conceding that “advice is not reaching all parts of the market”. However, it goes on to say that it thinks that one-off transactional advice, not ongoing advice, is the answer, saying: “Revenue from adviser charging continues to be dominated by ongoing advice services (76%), with only a quarter (26%) accounted for by one-off advice. Transactional advice is an important service for consumers investing smaller amounts of money.”

Dual challenge

So, the regulatory challenge for advisers is quite subtle. On one hand, the FCA believes that advice is the best way forward for people who need to take investment risks with part of their wealth, but it believes that an increase in transactional advice over ongoing advice is the answer.

For advisers to ensure that ongoing advice is seen in the proper light, it is important to explain the benefits of ongoing advice to clients in a way that they can understand and repeat to anyone who is looking to challenge the relationship they have with their adviser.

In a research document in December 2020, the FCA stated: “The evidence from our consumer research suggests that consumers who get financial advice do not always have a clear understanding of what financial advice costs. The consumer research shows that advised consumers think advice provides value for money. However, many were unaware how much they were paying and assessed its value by looking at the performance of their investments (which is distinct from the charges they are paying to have been placed in them).”

While it is, of course, important to disclose the cost of advice, it is also important to take time to ensure that the benefits are also understood. This includes:

  • Advice given during a market downturn, where avoiding the temptation to sell at the bottom of the market can make a huge difference.

  • Ongoing advice on the tax treatment of pensions and investment, where the wrong approach to disinvestment can lead to unnecessary tax costs.

  • Advice on avoiding scams, and on higher-risk investments that may be advertised without effectively highlighting the full extent of the risks involved.

The FCA has shown that it believes that advice is an important element in achieving good outcomes for consumers, but it has also expressed scepticism around the extent to which consumers should rely on ongoing advice.

The key to winning this argument is to create a population of clients who not only benefit from the undoubted advantages of ongoing advice, but who can articulate those advantages in the context of the fees that they are paying for advice.

As long as clients struggle to articulate the costs and benefits of the advice they receive, the regulator will always question the value of ongoing advice. It is only when clients can advocate for ongoing advice to the regulator that the FCA will be convinced of the need for a service that has undoubtedly delivered enormous benefits for consumers during the last decade.

Matthew Connell is director of policy and public affairs at the PFS

Image credit | iStock

Linked PFP_Spring 2022.jpg
This article appeared in our SPRING 2022 issue of Personal Finance Professional.
Click here to view this issue
Filed in
Features

You might also like...

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Today's top reads

BECOME A MEMBER

BECOME A MEMBER

SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT

SUBSCRIBE TO PRINT
PFP
​
FOLLOW US
Twitter
LinkedIn
Youtube
CONTACT US
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7880 6200
Email
Advertise with us
​

About the PFS

About us
Membership
Qualifications
Events

PFP magazine

Digital magazine
Podcasts
Blog
News

General Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Write for PFP Magazine
Want to receive PFP Magazine
Not a member but interested in knowing more? Click here.

© 2023 • PFP Magazine is published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ